Decided I would just bite the bullet, get the two AVP movies done. I actually remember a reasonable bit about this one, as while the movie is not considered good, it has a lot of memorable moments I feel. Most of the practical effects are good and the CG most of the time holds up too. That's about all the good I can say for the movie. The characters are all pretty stock, the PG-13 rating neuters the hell out of the experience, and things like two of the three predators dying at the halfway point of the movie just undercuts what should've been a much cooler experience.
Wasted potential is what I feel this movie is. It's not terrible, it has some cool moments (That first Alien vs Predator fight where shit is just getting smashed up is pretty great), but it feels like it could've been something way more. I honestly might put this over Predators as something I'd rather watch again. Predators is the more regular Predator experience, a throwback to the original, but honestly it wasn't anything special or had stuff that really stood out to me that wasn't just a nod to the original.
Also something I kinda just realized, but wasn't the whole point of the Predator movies involving heat, was that the Predators required a very hot environment to kinda survive in? Was I wrong in thinking that? Because with that in mind, how did the Predators survive in the Antarctic with basically nothing on them? Just a little thing I noticed that either seems like an error or I misunderstood the meaning behind the heat plot point lol
I went in, kinda expecting to not really like either of these, as I didn't have great memories of them, but I actually don't hate them. The problem with Requiem is that for most of it, I get more of a Friday the 13th vibe than I do Aliens or Predator. The characters aren't much of anything, writing is a mixed bag, and it's really dark for a whole lot of the movie so you don't get a good look at a lot of things. It's great that it's R-rated again, it doesn't feel neutered like the first movie, but it sorta feels like it was for nothing when you can't see a lot of what is going on. Again, it seems like there is good stuff here, I like that this whole town is basically getting screwed over by the xenomorphs, but the movie doesn't pull it together.
Having seen them all, other than the one out next month, my placement is going to be...Predator 1987, Predator 2, Predators, Alien vs Predator, and Aliens vs Predator: Requiem. Like I said, I'd probably rather watch AVP over Predators more often than not, but I still think Predators is probably better in general for just being a more pure Predator movie.