What's wrong with Backloggery?
Oh, there's just too much going on visually, but there's also not enough going on site-wise. Adding games manually to my personal list seems weird (with so many other gamers who probably have the same list of titles), and there should be a feature to see who else has backlogged the same game. I know it's not a database, but those just seem like ways to make it easier for all users.
... I guess I want something simpler, like a simple list of games that can be rearranged pretty easily with a little checkmark to indicate if it's done or not. But I also don't want to type out every single game that's on my backlog (pretty much most of my collection :p ). Thus my old suggestion that'd it'd be cool if this site had a backlog feature...
.. but I know that'd open up a whole 'nother can of worms for the mods.
Maybe I should learn how to make a real website and just do it myself!