Hmmm, ok I'll rescan the game at a lower resolution. I had it set to a high level from scanning some family photos so they're at 2400 x 2800 pixels and over 4 meg each for front, back and media. So perhaps that is the problem.
EDIT - I made a new one with a small front box art I found online and that seemed to work. So it probably was picture size then. A mod can go ahead and delete the two blank ones above. Thanks