The Rejected Edits thread

[tripredacus]

Playstation 3 [NA]
MLB 12: The Show http://vgcollect.com/item/25183
Image on file is stock photo. A release with 3 lines under the ESRB rating does not exist. Tried to replace image but was rejected.

[desocietas]

Playstation 3 [NA]
MLB 12: The Show http://vgcollect.com/item/25183
Image on file is stock photo. A release with 3 lines under the ESRB rating does not exist. Tried to replace image but was rejected.

Hmm, usually the admin will allow the edit unless it's not a great replacement. You can always try to resubmit. That's worked for me before. What was their reasoning for the rejection?

[SilverBow]

I have discovered 5 artworks variants presumably for the PS3 "MLB 12: The Show" game, all with an ESRB rating:

  1. Red Sox player on front artwork
  2. Blue Jays player on front artwork - maybe for Canada
  3. Texas Player on front artwork
  4. A woman with an "American" jersey - don't know what that's all about
  5. Texas player with cover having 2 "#1 Rated Sports Game" seals - one in English, one in French - probably a Canadian release.

Maybe you can enter it as a new variant.

[tripredacus]

What was their reasoning for the rejection?

Already on file. It might have been a bad crop. I will try again on Monday.

Silverbow, usually when I find variants I add them. My last round of edits only dealt with items I added to my collection. In those cases, I usually don't go overboard. I will look into getting those other releases you mentioned figured out next week as well.

[karyann]

If you submitted a properly cropped scan it should indeed be changed. Please try submitting it again