VGCollect Forum

General and Gaming => General => Topic started by: desocietas on September 23, 2011, 01:23:13 pm

Title: Buy It / Don't Buy It?
Post by: desocietas on September 23, 2011, 01:23:13 pm
A little thread to help me (and anyone else!) decide whether to purchase something or not at the price listed:

Fable II (360), pre-owned (will only buy if CIB) - $4.99 @ Gamestop
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: scott on September 23, 2011, 03:17:06 pm
I'd like a rating system, maybe a little 5 star vote or something. The tough part is all the variations will be rated differently, unless there is a way to link them.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: darko on September 23, 2011, 03:19:21 pm
I've never played it but several of my friends did and they loved it. I've actually never played any of the Fable games. I'd say for $5.00 buy it!

I would also like to see a rating system.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on September 23, 2011, 03:29:41 pm
I'd say for $5.00 buy it!

Thanks!  I'll swing by the game shop after work today :)  I know... for $5, it's like "why not?"  I don't have any of the others, and never really got to play much of the original (which goes for $15 used at Gamestop!).

Sometimes, all you need is a little urging from your peers.. XD
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on September 23, 2011, 03:33:39 pm
I'd like a rating system, maybe a little 5 star vote or something. The tough part is all the variations will be rated differently, unless there is a way to link them.


Good point.  I wonder if the site will ever have a little something added to each item record... like a "see also" or "related" list of links to other variations, sequels, and such.

Also, different ratings on different variations might be good for some things, like collector's editions, "director's cut," game of the year editions, etc. but definitely useless for the older games with variations like 3 or 5 screw.  Hmmmm.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: scott on September 23, 2011, 03:47:11 pm
I wonder if the site will ever have a little something added to each item record... like a "see also" or "related" list of links to other variations, sequels, and such.


That way you can see all the variations listed on a game's page.


Also, different ratings on different variations might be good for some things, like collector's editions, "director's cut," game of the year editions, etc. but definitely useless for the older games with variations like 3 or 5 screw.  Hmmmm.


Exactly, what's different about a game with a label variation? nothing at all, ha. So they should be the same score. But something like the Bioshock 2 Collectors Edition could use a different rating because of it's awesome goodies.

Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: amauriel on September 23, 2011, 05:26:17 pm
On the Fable II note, I loved it. I worked my way up until I owned so much property that everyone called me "Queen". Spent HOURS on that game.  For $5 I'd say great deal, I think I paid $40 and got my money's worth.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on September 23, 2011, 05:45:01 pm
Hah, this is going on the recently purchased thread, too:

I didn't see it initially on the racks, but the Gamestop guys seemed to sense exactly what I wanted and pulled a pre-owned copy from the back (with case, box art, manual, and disc).  Service!

Also, thanks for the advice, @amauriel and @darko!  I'm looking forward to this one (whenever I get around to playing it). Think I'll need to play through the first one at all to appreciate the sequel?
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: scott on September 23, 2011, 05:55:57 pm
I "bought" Fable II on Xbox Live's Games On Demand. Someone screwed up and had the game listed as Free. I was one of the ones to take advantage of it. I loved the original Fable, but I've not really sunk my teeth into Fable II. I've done a lot of crafting mini-games and have an annoying wife and a baby. ha
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: amauriel on September 23, 2011, 10:40:51 pm
I loved it and I've never played the first Fable. However, I HATED Fable III, the graphics were so jaggity/fragmented I gave up about 2 hours into it. I wonder if they ever patched that...
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on September 24, 2011, 01:45:35 am
I loved it and I've never played the first Fable. However, I HATED Fable III, the graphics were so jaggity/fragmented I gave up about 2 hours into it. I wonder if they ever patched that...


good to know! I almost got fable iii from TRU when they mispriced it for $15... they rescinded the order, but i figured it wasn't much of a loss, really.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on November 01, 2011, 01:36:49 pm
Looks like Scott Pilgrim will be 400 points for next week's XBLA sale... I heard it's brutally difficult (possibly buggy)... Any thoughts?
Buy it/don't buy it?

My account's actually on hold right now, too, so I wonder if I'd be able to buy it even if I wanted to.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: scott on November 01, 2011, 04:24:33 pm
Your account is on hold?

It's not hard, once you level up. Fully leveled I can blow through the game in roughly an hour. It's a really fun game, I only had it freeze up a couple times, and they fixed the major Store bug that was around when the game launched.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on November 01, 2011, 04:59:56 pm
It's not hard, once you level up. Fully leveled I can blow through the game in roughly an hour. It's a really fun game, I only had it freeze up a couple times, and they fixed the major Store bug that was around when the game launched.

Ok, good to know.  I really enjoyed the comics (haven't watched the movie yet :\) and am interested in how the game plays.  I'll see if I can call them to buy the game during the sale!

Your account is on hold?

Yeah, it sucks... I loaded 4000 points on my account a few weeks ago, and of course about a week later 3200 or so suddenly disappears.  After a bit of hunting on the terrible Microsoft/XBOX site, I found that someone used the points to buy Sims 3.  Still not sure how, since you can't download it to the Xbox as far as I can tell.

Customer support was really pleasant and said they should be able to refund me, but it'll require that my account be on hold until the investigation is complete (up to a month, blegh!).  So anything that requires me to log in, I can't do.

The most annoying part is that there's a competition for highest score going on for the Paranormal table on PFX2, and I can't participate (with my gamertag)!
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: scott on November 01, 2011, 05:39:32 pm
Oh that is laaaame. At least they are working on getting you fixed up.

Also, the only other thing that could be a turn off for Scott Pilgrim is the lack of online multiplayer, Its local only.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on April 26, 2012, 04:15:32 pm
Ok, got some Gamefly dollars I gotta use before the end of tomorrow... Help me pick out one of these!

After the discount:

Final Fantasy XIII-2 (XBOX 360): $15.19 used
Sonic Generations (XBOX 360): $7.99 used

Things to consider:
- I own FF XIII on PS3 (but I don't have a PS3 right now) and never got around to getting past the 20-hour threshold necessary to "enjoy" the game
- I don't really like platformers and really just played the first one or two levels of Sonic (Genesis) when I was young.  My favorite parts of the Sonic series were the bonus pinball stages and multiplayer (which this one does not have outside of racing).

Any thoughts?  Maybe there are other games on sale worth my money and Gamefly dollars?
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: jobocan on April 26, 2012, 04:53:36 pm
Frankly I'd go with Sonic Generations. It's an amazing game.  It may even get you into platformers! And you're getting it for super cheap anyways.

FFXIII-2 is also really good though... But I'd say it's only worth it if you really enjoy the battle system in XIII, since it's very much the same here (there are minor differences, but nothing really noticeable). It does improve on just about every problematic aspect of XIII though, so I'd probably give it a chance eventually if you like the fighting in XIII.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: madmax on April 26, 2012, 05:01:26 pm
I'd say Final Fantasy but I am a little biased :P That 20 hour buffer on the first game really does hurt the series though :(
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: jcalder8 on April 26, 2012, 05:20:49 pm
I would go with FF just because you said you don't like platformers.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on April 27, 2012, 11:38:02 am
Sweet, I think I'll go with ... FF?  I figure I'll buy Generations eventually as the price has been going down pretty steadily.  FF XIII-2 will probably hover around its current price (lowest I've seen is maybe $25?) for a while.

I feel bad that I'll have FF XIII on PS3 and FF XIII-2 on 360, but hey, that's how it goes.  Will probably never get a PS3 before the next gen on consoles comes out (though the rumors are saying the next PS console will likely not have backwards compatibility with the PS3?).

Do you think I'll need to have played XIII before playing XIII-2?  Or is it a pretty separate story?
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: jobocan on April 27, 2012, 11:52:45 am
Do you think I'll need to have played XIII before playing XIII-2?  Or is it a pretty separate story?

The ending of XIII is pretty important, but that's really about it, and even then you get that info within the game. For the most part the game does well to give you the information you need.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on April 27, 2012, 12:13:24 pm
Do you think I'll need to have played XIII before playing XIII-2?  Or is it a pretty separate story?

The ending of XIII is pretty important, but that's really about it, and even then you get that info within the game. For the most part the game does well to give you the information you need.

Sweet, good to know.  Thanks, all, for your advice!  Much appreciated :)
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on May 25, 2012, 04:02:44 pm
Ok, a few days left on this BIN... buy it / don't buy it?  haven't figured out the usual going rate for this item yet...

http://www.ebay.com/itm/170846819021?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: scott on May 25, 2012, 04:14:07 pm
Ok, a few days left on this BIN... buy it / don't buy it?  haven't figured out the usual going rate for this item yet...

http://www.ebay.com/itm/170846819021?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649

Hmm. I'm not sure. I know I paid $15 a piece for my Complete GBA Castlevania games (except the Dual Pack), they have all the inserts as well. I'd say it may be worth it for Pokemon Pinball R&S too.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on May 25, 2012, 05:35:53 pm
I forgot I'm already bidding on a copy that has the manual, game, case and no extra inserts for $6 (winning so far)... and that auction ends before the BIN does.  So we'll see what happens in a few days.

Thanks for the input!

I'm looking into Pokemon Pinball (the one with Pikachu on the front), but the prices are all over the place for it.  Hopefully I won't have to pay over $15 for that one, but I keep seeing it for $25+ so far.  It's got a Rumble Pak - do those have a tendency to stop working?
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on November 17, 2012, 02:25:57 am
Toys 'R' Us just emailed a coupon for a free Skylanders Spyro's Adventure Stater Pack with purchase of a Giants Starter Pack (Wii)...

I don't own it yet and wasn't sure if this was a good deal or not.  Any thoughts?

Also, any thoughts on which console it'd be best for?  I don't own a Wii, but I figure I will (or something compatible with Wii games) in the future.  This coupon seems to be only for the Wii version.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: exonerator on November 19, 2012, 02:28:10 pm
I'd like to see /100 rather than /5.

My 2 cents.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: darko on November 21, 2012, 04:06:37 pm
Has anyone spent any amount of time with Blue Dragon: Awakened Shadow on the DS? I messed around with the game for about 30 minutes the other day and it seemed pretty decent. Just looking for a little more input before I buy it and find out 2 hours in that it's total garbage.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: jcalder8 on November 21, 2012, 05:20:00 pm
My sister-in-law is a big RPG gamer and she enjoyed playing through Blue Dragon on the DS, I haven't tried it myself though.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on November 21, 2012, 05:45:15 pm
I thought I'd eventually get it for the DS, but the reviews from Metacritic have been so varied, I haven't picked it up yet.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: soera on November 21, 2012, 06:03:36 pm
Toys 'R' Us just emailed a coupon for a free Skylanders Spyro's Adventure Stater Pack with purchase of a Giants Starter Pack (Wii)...

I don't own it yet and wasn't sure if this was a good deal or not.  Any thoughts?

Also, any thoughts on which console it'd be best for?  I don't own a Wii, but I figure I will (or something compatible with Wii games) in the future.  This coupon seems to be only for the Wii version.

This isnt a bad deal if you want both games. You get Spyro/Gill Grunt/Trigger Happy with the spyro set and Jet Vac/Cynder/Tree Rex with the Giant set. You can play both sets of characters on Giants and setting the ownership of the first 3 on your giants game gives you a bigger exp bonus. The console is just whichever you prefer. If you have a DS, that is probably the one I would choose if you use it cause the actual characters you get are bonus characters on that and the portal on the DS system is universal and doesnt use batteries so you dont have to worry about it running out of power. If you have a PS3 getting the Giants starter kit comes with a wired portal as well and its definitely a preferred option over the wireless one that come with Spyros.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on November 21, 2012, 06:47:19 pm
Hm, good to know.  Unfortunately, that coupon was for last Saturday only, and I ended up deciding against dropping $80 on a couple of games that I may or may not even play for who knows how long (don't have a Wii right now).

Thanks for the thoughts on the console choices!  I might still pick it up sometime since it's gotten such good reception, but I don't *need* it.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: desocietas on November 29, 2013, 08:37:11 pm
$30 for Muramasa Rebirth Blessing of Amitabha Edition (collector's edition)... buy it / don't buy it?
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: disgaeniac on November 30, 2013, 07:25:48 am
I've got no problem w/ users rating games; hell, I have no problem rating the games that I play, either.

BIG DISCLAIMER & note though = "Ratings" are so very, very, very subjective -and- are basically just 1 person's *opinion* of the game in question.

For example: Me, Kimimi, Erik, and Brad *might* rate certain games similarly...I'd always rate Disgaea games highly...however...for many other users who aren't into steep learning-curves, necessary (post-game, at least) grinding/farming, and a time investment of 100+ hours; obviously, the game would/should get & reflect a very low rating for them.

There are others into Shooters/Shmups, etc -that- even if rated highly by others, would still always (simply by default) never rate higher than a 1 or 2...to *ME*.

I mean, I'd be happy to give my opinions on games, and I can enjoy reading other's opinions of other games & genres -but- as a device to convince/disuade another member here from spending/not spending their money (unless, of course, we're only talking about a few bucks); I think it could have horribly negative (unintended) effects...

*subtracts 2 cents from checking balance*   :P
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It? (or Should We Start Rating Games?)
Post by: kimimi on November 30, 2013, 11:45:06 am
I agree completely, and this is exactly why I refrain from doing reviews on my blog - and even when I do write reviews elsewhere (http://www.retrocollect.com/Reviews/retro-review-densha-de-go-2-neo-geo-pocket-color.html) I avoid scoring or anything like that.

So yeah, I'm happy to give *my* opinion, but if I do please don't take it as anything more than that.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It?
Post by: desocietas on November 30, 2013, 01:26:59 pm
I decided to amend the title of the post since the post is older and a bunch of us had already talked about it back then when it was new.  But I agree with what Kimimi and Disgaeniac have said so far.

What I have enjoyed is hearing folks trying out games that I've been curious about and seeing what they think about it.  I don't tend to read reviews as I worry too much about spoilers and being biased about something before I even try it myself, but I appreciate when reviews make sure to go over the basics of game functionality and design.  Does it lag? Do the graphics appear outdated?  Do the graphics matter?  Is there a tutorial, and is it any good / how long does it last?

But yes, it can be very subjective as different games appeal to different folks for all sorts of reasons.  For example, I've been strangely addicted to Hometown Story and, while it admittedly has a *lot* of faults, I find myself strangely compelled to play it over Animal Crossing: New Leaf which has plenty of acclaim (but currently bores me).

I still hesitate to recommend Hometown Story, though, and have even bought Animal Crossing for friends as gifts.


Anywayyy.... TL;DR: Reviews are definitely subjective, and I bought Muramasa anyway :)
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It?
Post by: scott on November 30, 2013, 01:45:39 pm
TL;DR: Reviews are definitely subjective, and I bought 4 copies of Muramasa anyway :)

fixed that for you.
Title: Re: Buy It / Don't Buy It?
Post by: desocietas on November 30, 2013, 01:46:21 pm
TL;DR: Reviews are definitely subjective, and I bought 4 copies of Muramasa anyway :)

fixed that for you.

hahaha you don't know me!

*quickly checks Amazon to see if they're still on sale*