I went into Man of Steel with the idea of whether I was still alright with it, if my views of the later films skewed things too much, and in general, not a lot changed, it's just an okay film.
Batman v Superman though, I went in knowing I thought this movie was just all wrong and on a new rewatch with the Ultimate Edition that adds an extra half hour, I found more things to dislike about it lol
Something I never noticed before was why did Bruce show up to Metropolis? An alien threat appears and his first instinct is to not suit up, get in his jet or car, and try to do something, he instead decides to just rush to his building in a civilian car? Why not take the helicopter he was already riding in if he was just gonna try to evacuate the building? I know this was all so they could fit Bruce into things after the fact, but it doesn't really make any sense and I didn't realize it on first watch. It's also really dumb that Jimmy Olson makes an appearance just to turn out to be a CIA agent who gets killed.
While I do like how Batman looks in this, I think Affleck is fine for the role too, I hate what they do with him, making him brand criminals so they can be killed, he has this completely random, yet incredibly specific nightmare/vision of Superman taking over that makes no sense because it also uses Darkseid related imagery for it, they just have Batman using guns and killing people outright, both in that nightmare, and in the real world, and I don't think it's clear that the Flash bit is connected to that vision, because the vision is a dream within a dream. Its baffling and I know they are bringing the "Nightmare" stuff back in the Snyder Cut of Justice League, something I don't remember if it was in the original JL movie or not.
Lex Luthor sucks in this, I know they try to say he's not THAT Lex, even though it is, it still doesn't work at all. They have him play it like he's The Riddler or something, it's completely awful. I will say that I think this movie looks slightly better maybe than Man of Steel, it's not quite as washed out, but I still don't particularly love how it looks. It's just the Snyder style, it's dark.
To me, the greatest problem of this movie is what its about. Batman v Superman. It's two very well known DC storylines, the Dark Knight Returns, and the Death of Superman, all at once, in a movie that also establishes their Batman, Wonder Woman, and is setting up the Justice League. This was DC rushing to catch up to Marvel as fast as they could, without putting the same work in to set up everything. They took two great stories and ruined them. Like Batman v Superman should've been it's own thing later on. The Death of Superman could've been a multi-movie long thing where the different character movies dealt with what happened, bringing in all the different Supermen, it would've been awesome...but it just...wasn't. Doomsday is just a bio-engineered Zod. Batman v Superman is a fight scene stopped because they both have a mom named Martha. The Justice League is created without a Superman. Heck, Luthor somehow figured out both Superman's and Batman's identity. This is all in one movie. It is nonsense and not nearly as epic as they tried to make it out to be.
I will give this movie one thing...I think the fight between Batman and Superman is pretty good. It's honestly kind of a weak movie up till this fight, it's so much setup, there's not a lot of great Batman stuff, no good Superman stuff, it's all put into this ending, which again, I do like, the following Batman fight is cool too, even if he is killing people with guns, but I got nothing for the Doomsday stuff, it's just an iconic villain wasted in an over stylized, mess of a fight that the DCEU stuff generally likes to do. Like I said before, it's like watching video game cutscenes. I can admit to seeing Wonder Woman, Batman, and Superman all posed up as being kinda cool lol
In the end, I still think this movie mostly sucks and a new watch only didn't improve it, it mostly made it worse. This is what turned me against the DCEU completely with only a few bright spots after this with Wonder Woman, Shazam, and even Aquaman for how goofy it is. Though it took a turn for the worse again with Birds of Prey and and WW84. Original Justice League is next. I am going into it with a very different mindset having learned what that movie went through, which is a lot...This will be more about how it compares to the Snyder Cut and what Snyders vision for Justice League actually was.
And because I couldn't sleep and I had trouble getting Justice League to run right for whatever reason, I saw
X-Men: Dark Phoenix and figured I'd watch that, finish up the X-Men series as it was. I heard it was bad beforehand, though I always meant to watch it, but I honestly just found it kinda boring. The villains are nothing, most of the character stuff and action has been done before in previous films, and none of the action is exciting until the final fight on the train. If you haven't seen it, there's really no reason to see it unless you are a die hard fan who just hasn't seen it already for whatever reason, and even then, there's not alot here for the end of the series.