Listing Errors 2016

[sinestro417]

I got a Rejected on this after submitting the correct box art. I was told it was the incorrect box art. As I own the game I know what the box art looks like. The correct image was submitted.

http://vgcollect.com/item/110148

Your image was missing the white rectangle logo that shows up on the upper left side. It can be seen in the existing picture and also on other images I used as reference. Better pictures are great, but removing information is not ok. If your game does not have this logo on it, we can discuss whether or not you have a variation worthy of having a new entry.

That white logo in the top left is on the wrap not on the box art itself. Its impossible to get it on a scan of the box art. All it is, is "The Official Product of the World Cup Logo".

[tripredacus]

I got a Rejected on this after submitting the correct box art. I was told it was the incorrect box art. As I own the game I know what the box art looks like. The correct image was submitted.

http://vgcollect.com/item/110148

Your image was missing the white rectangle logo that shows up on the upper left side. It can be seen in the existing picture and also on other images I used as reference. Better pictures are great, but removing information is not ok. If your game does not have this logo on it, we can discuss whether or not you have a variation worthy of having a new entry.

That white logo in the top left is on the wrap not on the box art itself. Its impossible to get it on a scan of the box art. All it is, is "The Official Product of the World Cup Logo".

The db entry should still have this label on the picture. In the description, a note can be made that the label is on the outside plastic of the factory sealed release, and used or resealed copies will be missing that label.

[Flashback2012]

Looking for some help on this...

Gal Gun: Double Peace
http://vgcollect.com/item/107905

I submitted an edit for the name to get it more in line with other releases such as this http://vgcollect.com/item/109216 which is listed as Gal*Gun: Double Peace.

I'm thinking perhaps I used the wrong symbol of Shift+8 or "*". Should it be Alt+42 or "*"? Not going to lie but I can't tell the difference between the two. For that matter, should ANY of the listings have the "*" in the name? 

Any alt-code gurus want to take a stab at this? 

[washerdryercombo]

http://vgcollect.com/item/1634

I tried to edit the Publisher of this title to Sony because they ARE the publisher of the title and it was rejected. Any reason why?

Sony Published titles have SCUS as their Item Number code instead of the usual SLUS, Treasure Planet also uses SCUS.

[tripredacus]

Looking for some help on this...

Gal Gun: Double Peace
http://vgcollect.com/item/107905

I submitted an edit for the name to get it more in line with other releases such as

There is no appropriate character to put into the title to replace the star. The star is a design of the logo and is not a letter or punctuation so it should not be in the title. Any other entry that uses an asterisk in the title to be a star as seen in a logo should not be there either.

[tripredacus]

http://vgcollect.com/item/1634

I tried to edit the Publisher of this title to Sony because they ARE the publisher of the title and it was rejected. Any reason why?

Sony Published titles have SCUS as their Item Number code instead of the usual SLUS, Treasure Planet also uses SCUS.

Publisher is Sony Computer Entertainment of America or SCEA.
I didn't reject or see this edit.

[washerdryercombo]

http://vgcollect.com/item/1634

I tried to edit the Publisher of this title to Sony because they ARE the publisher of the title and it was rejected. Any reason why?

Sony Published titles have SCUS as their Item Number code instead of the usual SLUS, Treasure Planet also uses SCUS.

Publisher is Sony Computer Entertainment of America or SCEA.
I didn't reject or see this edit.

I reedited it, it is strange that Sony published this game and the Stitch 626 game.

[Flashback2012]

Looking for some help on this...

Gal Gun: Double Peace
http://vgcollect.com/item/107905

I submitted an edit for the name to get it more in line with other releases such as

There is no appropriate character to put into the title to replace the star. The star is a design of the logo and is not a letter or punctuation so it should not be in the title. Any other entry that uses an asterisk in the title to be a star as seen in a logo should not be there either.

I figured that would be the response. I also figured it would be easier to edit just this one to conform to the others instead of editing the others to conform to this one. Looks like that's what needs to be done though, thanks Trip. 

[telly]

Looking for some help on this...

Gal Gun: Double Peace
http://vgcollect.com/item/107905

I submitted an edit for the name to get it more in line with other releases such as

There is no appropriate character to put into the title to replace the star. The star is a design of the logo and is not a letter or punctuation so it should not be in the title. Any other entry that uses an asterisk in the title to be a star as seen in a logo should not be there either.

I figured that would be the response. I also figured it would be easier to edit just this one to conform to the others instead of editing the others to conform to this one. Looks like that's what needs to be done though, thanks Trip. 

Shouldn't the official title be taken into consideration though? If the title includes a star in the official name and it's what's on the box art shouldn't it also be in the title on VGC?

If that's not the case, then all the Idolm@ster games I edited are completely wrong 

[tripredacus]

Looking for some help on this...

Gal Gun: Double Peace
http://vgcollect.com/item/107905

I submitted an edit for the name to get it more in line with other releases such as

There is no appropriate character to put into the title to replace the star. The star is a design of the logo and is not a letter or punctuation so it should not be in the title. Any other entry that uses an asterisk in the title to be a star as seen in a logo should not be there either.

I figured that would be the response. I also figured it would be easier to edit just this one to conform to the others instead of editing the others to conform to this one. Looks like that's what needs to be done though, thanks Trip. 

Shouldn't the official title be taken into consideration though? If the title includes a star in the official name and it's what's on the box art shouldn't it also be in the title on VGC?

If that's not the case, then all the Idolm@ster games I edited are completely wrong 

@ is a valid character, but Idolmaster should be in alt-name field too to help with searches. But I am not saying you need to go fix all those entries.

Regarding Gal Gun, actually it should be in the db as one word instead of two.
Even look at the Japanese site, above the logo the text version has no star in it:
http://www.galgun.com/W/

Here is just the logo in case you don't want to go to the site because of work/school:

[telly]

I think I misunderstood when I read "The star is a design of the logo and is not a letter or punctuation so it should not be in the title" I thought you were saying that no symbols or special characters at all should be allowed in the database titles.

Yeah, I'll definitely go back through those Idolmaster titles and make sure they're consistent

[kam1kaz3nl77]

http://vgcollect.com/item/94261 & http://vgcollect.com/item/94260  both European releases but both showing a front box cover of an USA version!

[tripredacus]

http://vgcollect.com/item/94261 & http://vgcollect.com/item/94260  both European releases but both showing a front box cover of an USA version!

Merged and removed from cover.

[telly]

http://vgcollect.com/item/108858

The disc is incorrectly for the German release, can we have it removed?

I just created a German variant for it
http://vgcollect.com/item/112941

Thanks

[fazerco]

http://vgcollect.com/item/108858

The disc is incorrectly for the German release, can we have it removed?

I just created a German variant for it
http://vgcollect.com/item/112941

Thanks

It is common here in Europe that there is a Pegi box, and have USK and the Australian thingy on the disc. Ive seen it before.