Another incoming rant - I need to learn to stay away from GameStop.com It's often tempting with B2G1 sales and holiday sales with good prices, but the quality and condition of the stuff they ship you will not be. Took the risk, and got a disc only used game that looks like someone spilled something on it, and that thing is going straight back. I also got a "new" copy of Outer Worlds, but unsurprisingly no shrink wrap and not even a sticker saying it was "NEW", disc was rolling around inside. For all I know, it could very well be a used copy since they have no standard of what constitutes as a new copy. Often they run out of new copies fast, because they don't invest in nearly half as much stock as their competitors.
I might give them a pass for not caring much about the condition of used games, but when new stock is treated in much the same manner to where you can't tell the difference, I have big problem with that. Have to remember to stay away if at all possible. eBay is the best place to pick up games online, new or used.