A few rejected edits (PS1 PAL)

[rberggren]

Your edit to 360: Three Sixty was rejected.
Game: http://vgcollect.com/item/58780
Field: Name
New Value: 360 Three Sixty
---
The Parent Title is set without any special character, which makes the semicolon unnecessary and wrong, as 360 is not a part of any series.
Reference: http://www.defconsoft.co.uk/database.php?clas=1&game=34

Your edit to 007: Racing was rejected.
Game: http://vgcollect.com/item/58770
Field: Name
New Value: 007 Racing
---
The Parent Title is set without any special character, which makes the semicolon unnecessary and wrong. On the contrary, the other 007-games have a - between 007 and the subtitle.
Reference 1: http://www.defconsoft.co.uk/database.php?clas=1&game=1
Reference 2: http://www.defconsoft.co.uk/database.php?clas=1&game=5

Your edit to Disney's: Goofy's Fun House was rejected.
Game: http://vgcollect.com/item/58752
Field: Name
New Value: Goofy's Fun House
And
Field: alt_name
New Value: Disney's Goofy's Fun House
---
The Parent Title is set without "Disney's", and "Disney's" is so small printed that it looks more like a branding than a part of the title. Therefore, the title would be more correct by removing "Disney's" from the main title - but adding it to the alternative title.
Reference: http://www.defconsoft.co.uk/database.php?clas=1&game=1129
Example: http://vgcollect.com/item/58773

EDIT: As examples show in the style guide (btw, the linking to that guide from the notification-page is broken, you get sent to the notification-page again instead of the style guide) i COULD approve with entry 1 and 2 being denied. But entry 3, I really think that would've and should've gone trough.

[soera]

I was the one that rejected those. If for no other reason but clarity did I reject the first two. The last one was a necessary reject. The game specifically states Disney's Goofy's fun house. If you want to delete the Disney's part for an alternate name, that would be acceptable.

[rberggren]

I certainly do see your point, but what I also have in mind are the complications that could occur, which would break the standard formating.

A title like Goofy's example is perfectly fine and would work, if it weren't for games like i.e. Disney's Hercules Action Game. "Action Game" is not written on the cover as a part of the main title and are therefore to be taken as a subtitle - making the title (following Goofy's example) to be like "Disney's: Hercules: Action Game".. and that looks way wrong in my eyes

EDIT: The game as reference http://vgcollect.com/item/49497 (yeah, the cover is in German, which is noted to change into EU/EN).

[90snostalga]

I was the one that rejected those. If for no other reason but clarity did I reject the first two. The last one was a necessary reject. The game specifically states Disney's Goofy's fun house. If you want to delete the Disney's part for an alternate name, that would be acceptable.

Your an admin now?

[soera]

I certainly do see your point, but what I also have in mind are the complications that could occur, which would break the standard formating.

A title like Goofy's example is perfectly fine and would work, if it weren't for games like i.e. Disney's Hercules Action Game. "Action Game" is not written on the cover as a part of the main title and are therefore to be taken as a subtitle - making the title (following Goofy's example) to be like "Disney's: Hercules: Action Game".. and that looks way wrong in my eyes

EDIT: The game as reference http://vgcollect.com/item/49497 (yeah, the cover is in German, which is noted to change into EU/EN).

The game you mentioned should be Disney's Hercules. Action game part is just a description of the game, not part of the actual name.

[soera]

I was the one that rejected those. If for no other reason but clarity did I reject the first two. The last one was a necessary reject. The game specifically states Disney's Goofy's fun house. If you want to delete the Disney's part for an alternate name, that would be acceptable.

Your an admin now?

As of this moment, Im trying to help out with the edits cause of busy schedules on a lot of the admin. Whether Matt decides to make it an official thing or not is up to him.

[soera]

I certainly do see your point, but what I also have in mind are the complications that could occur, which would break the standard formating.

A title like Goofy's example is perfectly fine and would work, if it weren't for games like i.e. Disney's Hercules Action Game. "Action Game" is not written on the cover as a part of the main title and are therefore to be taken as a subtitle - making the title (following Goofy's example) to be like "Disney's: Hercules: Action Game".. and that looks way wrong in my eyes

EDIT: The game as reference http://vgcollect.com/item/49497 (yeah, the cover is in German, which is noted to change into EU/EN).

I went back and looked at some of the other Disney games such as Chip and Dale and Duck Tales and a lot of those do not list the Disney in the title ... so for consistancy sake, if you resubmit them as you originally did, I will accept them.

[90snostalga]

I was the one that rejected those. If for no other reason but clarity did I reject the first two. The last one was a necessary reject. The game specifically states Disney's Goofy's fun house. If you want to delete the Disney's part for an alternate name, that would be acceptable.

Your an admin now?

As of this moment, Im trying to help out with the edits cause of busy schedules on a lot of the admin. Whether Matt decides to make it an official thing or not is up to him.

Ahh,  well good luck 

[rberggren]

I went back and looked at some of the other Disney games such as Chip and Dale and Duck Tales and a lot of those do not list the Disney in the title ... so for consistancy sake, if you resubmit them as you originally did, I will accept them.

Thanks for taking your time to dig such deep into this, the data regarding Goofy's Fun House is now resubmitted. Much appreciated!

[soera]

Yeah I approved them.

[foxhack]

... what

I take a break for a little bit and I'm replaced? ;_;

[soera]

One less thing to deal with is all.