Listing Errors 2016

[corexretro]

Found this error while doing a stroll through the 3DS section

Shin Megami Tensei IV Final (3DS) [NA]
http://vgcollect.com/item/96316

As far as I am aware of, this game hasn't even been announced for the west and it is listed as a NA title.

[tripredacus]

^ that game I set to be removed. I can find no release date either. If the game does get an actual release date or at least an ESRB rating, then it can be added again.

I found this one while perusing the Wii selection...

Kororinpa
http://vgcollect.com/item/27052

The UK/EU box art was used and based on the information/release date of that listing, I'm thinking it should be this one... http://vgcollect.com/item/41271

Processed that as a dupe.

[fazerco]

Empty entry

http://vgcollect.com/item/99051

[pacpix]

Empty entry

http://vgcollect.com/item/99051

Removed

[rayne315]

Sonic Adventure DX: Director's Cut - Sold Out

http://vgcollect.com/item/99261

I put this here because I am really confused why in the title it has "Sold out"

EDIT:

I now noticed why its called sold out but I am still unaware why they decided to add this particular publisher in the title and even still it should be "Sold Out Software" because that's the full name of the publisher

[Flashback2012]

I was trying to clean up some Skylanders entries this morning and got a bunch rejected (I really wish there was a way you could see who performed the edit so they could be contacted directly). The rejects were in regards to some ratings and genres. The packages don't have ratings on them and I was looking at the style guide for that and saw this...

"If your item has no rating of any kind, choose "None". This applies to all consoles and systems." which is what I've done a bunch of times and the edits have gotten approved without incident. I can only assume the mod is citing this "If your item has no rating anywhere on the package, do not make one up so you can add it to its listing" which IMO isn't what I'm doing, I was following the former. I also had the same thing occur to the Game Gear game Putt & Putter which was released prior to any ESRB or VRC. Again, I've submitted edits of "NONE" for other games released before ratings were adopted and they've been approved in the past.

Also in regards to trying to add or change the genre for the Skylanders, some were blank/unfilled and others had "Adventure" listed. I'd contest that while the games themselves are "Adventure" games, the FIGURES themselves are not and given that there isn't a "NONE" choice, I've been selecting "Other" for them (which again have been getting approved without issue). I had put off cleaning up the rest of the Skylanders section for a while and was about to start that again but can I get a consensus of what the PTB want in the fields before I do? 

[tripredacus]

Sonic Adventure DX: Director's Cut - Sold Out

http://vgcollect.com/item/99261

I put this here because I am really confused why in the title it has "Sold out"

EDIT:

I now noticed why its called sold out but I am still unaware why they decided to add this particular publisher in the title and even still it should be "Sold Out Software" because that's the full name of the publisher

You can submit an edit to add the full publisher name. It is in the title because it is a different packaging type than the regular EU/UK releases, which come in black, blue and white label.

[metshael]

http://vgcollect.com/item/51797

It's an European PlayStation version of Final Fantasy V, well yes it's been released on that console but in Europe it's only been released with Final Fantasy IV in the European version of Final Fantasy Anthology (and on GBA too... but that's another story). Maybe someone only found the disc for FF5 and made that entry but it's not really hard to find where that disc came from since a "Final Fantasy Anthology" is also that disc, so... do we accept separate entry for compilations like this one ?

[tripredacus]

http://vgcollect.com/item/51797

It's an European PlayStation version of Final Fantasy V, well yes it's been released on that console but in Europe it's only been released with Final Fantasy IV in the European version of Final Fantasy Anthology (and on GBA too... but that's another story). Maybe someone only found the disc for FF5 and made that entry but it's not really hard to find where that disc came from since a "Final Fantasy Anthology" is also that disc, so... do we accept separate entry for compilations like this one ?

Well it seems that is only an entry for the soundtrack? And that it is a regular release CD rather than the soundtrack that was released in the Anthology. AND it would be a Japanese music CD?

[metshael]

Well it seems that is only an entry for the soundtrack? And that it is a regular release CD rather than the soundtrack that was released in the Anthology. AND it would be a Japanese music CD?

To be honest i didn't even checked that cover, i thought it was just some random FF5 picture chosen to represent that item and to have a more 'good-looking" collection, too bad he didn't add any data when he created it so we know if it's really the disc from FF Anthology or a dupe of that soundtrack.

[pajam]

Quick question about the little oddity on the PSP (NA) that is the "Hilton Garden Inn: Ultimate Team Play"
http://vgcollect.com/item/39756

I just had an edit rejected, in which I tried uploading a main Box Art image. The thing is, this game had no box, only a UMD and a PSP system were shipped to Hilton Garden Inns. Currently the Box Art is a logo for the hotel itself, not the "game" (training sim). To better represent the game, I exported a screenshot of the title screen from the game with the game title logo "HGI: Ultimate Team Play." However, this edit was rejected.

Title Screen:


Versus the current image which is a generic hotel chain logo:


In the past I've seen people say to use the title screen from in-game for any games that have no official box or box art representing it in any online marketplace. Yet in this case it was rejected, even though it seems the best case scenario for this UMD. Should I upload it again and hope for the best?

[tripredacus]

In the past I've seen people say to use the title screen from in-game for any games that have no official box or box art representing it in any online marketplace.

That is for digital released games. For this, since it is a loose pack-in item, it will have no front nor back box art. It would fall under the same rules as Nazo Puyo on the Game Gear:
http://vgcollect.com/item/9046

[pajam]

Okay, works for me. The UMD image I uploaded was accepted. But since the Front Box Art image that is currently on there doesn't really work for what this is, I figured a more accurate image was better than one that is less related.

[tripredacus]

I have removed the hotel logo as the Front Box Art.

[fazerco]

http://vgcollect.com/item/46169 might be a fake cover. If so it can be merged with http://vgcollect.com/item/28525