Error Listings 2017

[tripredacus]

That's what I was leaning to in my OP. The disc says both names on it, so even if you just have one disc, it's still a part of FFCC

I'm pretty sure this conversation came up and I'm fairly certain it was trip who said exactly that.  All listings on this site should represent how an item was packaged when it was sold.

I think we have had similar situations regarding controllers and such because sometimes certain accessories were only sold in bundles or something and that we shouldn't have them listed separate since they were never available separately.

Well what I think and how things work doesn't always match up. It was already a thing that pack-in items (even different games) *can* be allowed to have a separate entry. It is true of NFR things that come with a system or controller, or those situations where there are multiple games in one package such as the DOA set, GTA sets, Metal Gear Solid Essentials, etc OH and the Bayonetta on the Wii.

But the main issue here is that the site does not have the ability to link items to each other. Think of the Final Fantasy Chonicles entry as not having cart/case/manual/inserts options but instead has case/manual/FFIV CD/Chrono Trigger CD checkboxes. And then each of those 4 things can appear as search results. Even so, without that type of design, a user can still choose the pack itself and just note what they have... or as I do where I put incomplete items in my Wishlist and not collection.

I have sent a PM to the user who made the entry. I would prefer to merge it with FF Chronicles also.

[telly]

I guess what came to mind for me was the FFXII demo that was included with DQVIII. That's a separate entry because it's easy separated from DQVIII. But Chrono Trigger has FFCC on the disc, so it seems a little strange to separate it out of it's original entry.

I don't know if that makes sense though.

[aliensstudios]

I guess what came to mind for me was the FFXII demo that was included with DQVIII. That's a separate entry because it's easy separated from DQVIII. But Chrono Trigger has FFCC on the disc, so it seems a little strange to separate it out of it's original entry.

I don't know if that makes sense though.

Personally, I'd say keep it the way it is because there is a chance someone could only have the demo

[telly]

I guess what came to mind for me was the FFXII demo that was included with DQVIII. That's a separate entry because it's easy separated from DQVIII. But Chrono Trigger has FFCC on the disc, so it seems a little strange to separate it out of it's original entry.

I don't know if that makes sense though.

Personally, I'd say keep it the way it is because there is a chance someone could only have the demo

Keep the Chrono Trigger the way it is or the FFXII demo entry?

[aliensstudios]

I guess what came to mind for me was the FFXII demo that was included with DQVIII. That's a separate entry because it's easy separated from DQVIII. But Chrono Trigger has FFCC on the disc, so it seems a little strange to separate it out of it's original entry.

I don't know if that makes sense though.

Personally, I'd say keep it the way it is because there is a chance someone could only have the demo

Keep the Chrono Trigger the way it is or the FFXII demo entry?

I would keep it as Final Fantasy Chronicles: Chrono Trigger and for the artwork, use the disc artwork since the game itself has no artwork of its own, so the Final Fantasy Chronicles: Chrono Trigger's artwork would be this:

*I submitted that as an edit, so we'll see what happens

I would keep the FFXII demo exactly as it is personally. It makes note that it was included with Dragon Quest VIII and it uses the disc (the only artwork available) as the artwork.

This same thing happened a while ago, for the NA version of Bayonetta on Wii U, there is no cover art, it was bundled only with Bayonetta 2. I tried to change it a few times to the disc artwork because it had unofficial artwork. Finally I pm'ed and admin and they accepted the disc artwork as the game's artwork because that is the official (and only) artwork for the game.

[telly]

Sounds fine with me! Though I think the image you submitted is from the greatest hits release since it has GH in the item listing. I think the black label disc actually looks a little different.

[aliensstudios]

Sounds fine with me! Though I think the image you submitted is from the greatest hits release since it has GH in the item listing. I think the black label disc actually looks a little different.

Crud, that is the Greatest Hits version, how could I have missed that? I guess the fact that it didn't have a silver top threw me off. Turns out the black label disc is extremely similar:

[jjfly]

https://vgcollect.com/item/19614

totallycrushed has added Scandinavian barcode and Pegi rating (my Scandinavian version has VET/SFB rating) on Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec - Platinum USK rated version (if judged by front cover). 

[tripredacus]

https://vgcollect.com/item/19614

totallycrushed has added Scandinavian barcode and Pegi rating (my Scandinavian version has VET/SFB rating) on Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec - Platinum USK rated version (if judged by front cover).

Fixed artwork and barcode. I see on the disc that the item number has -P at the end, is it this way on the case also?

[jjfly]

https://vgcollect.com/item/19614

totallycrushed has added Scandinavian barcode and Pegi rating (my Scandinavian version has VET/SFB rating) on Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec - Platinum USK rated version (if judged by front cover).

Fixed artwork and barcode. I see on the disc that the item number has -P at the end, is it this way on the case also?

No, at least the Scandinavian version doesn't have.

[fazerco]

Edit made here
https://vgcollect.com/item/83499

Should be [NA].


While im at it, this one is wrong also:
https://vgcollect.com/item/65572
This is a [EU] Pictures with a [NA] barcode and item number. And that barcode and item number goes to my edit in this post.....
I can provide another barcode for this item do if a mod wants/needs it.

[jjfly]

Sorry wrong thread

[fazerco]

My country codes edit here https://vgcollect.com/item/83490 which i put in was denied. I put it in because of this version i entered, https://vgcollect.com/item/126740. It was done because people can see which version they have quickly.

[SilverBow]

Invizimals - PSP [NA]
https://vgcollect.com/item/18348
Improper rear box image. Unlike Invizimals: Shadow Zone, Invizimals was only released bundled with a camera. This is not the rear image of the cardboard box.

[tripredacus]

While im at it, this one is wrong also:
https://vgcollect.com/item/65572
This is a [EU] Pictures with a [NA] barcode and item number. And that barcode and item number goes to my edit in this post.....
I can provide another barcode for this item do if a mod wants/needs it.

I have removed that information so you can fix it.

My country codes edit here https://vgcollect.com/item/83490 which i put in was denied. I put it in because of this version i entered, https://vgcollect.com/item/126740. It was done because people can see which version they have quickly.

What can you tell me about these two items? The title for 126740 is not good. What is different between it and 83490?

Invizimals - PSP [NA]
https://vgcollect.com/item/18348
Improper rear box image. Unlike Invizimals: Shadow Zone, Invizimals was only released bundled with a camera. This is not the rear image of the cardboard box.

Back image is removed.