I appreciate the effort to do all this, though I probably would have taken a step further to size everything reasonably in photoshop.
Console: SwitchIt actually has some kind of innovation and isn't just a crappy PC 15% better then the previous crappy PCs.
Racing: Mario Kart 8 DeluxeI don't even like Mario Kart 8 relative to other Mario Karts, but it sure is better then realistic racing snoozefest #536.
Shooter: DoomI haven't played any of these, but when has that ever stopped a game journalist? Doom interests me the most, but I hear it's kind of shit on the Switch... sucks, man.
Side Scroller: CupheadIs this even the right category...? Ah, who cares, Cuphead is basically the best thing ever. Props to Sonic Mania... but if you didn't wanna lose to Cuphead in the prestigious MvC2 competition you should have come out a different year.
RPG: Pokemon Ultra Sun/MoonHaven't played the others... know enough about them. Hard to dethrone Pokemon even in cashgrab semi-demi-sequel mode.
3D Platformer: Mario OdysseyObviously. However, unlike most I liked Yooka-Laylee a lot and the Crash Trilogy is amazing and timeless. Odyssey is still better then either. Hat in Time was not what I ended up wanting, but you could throw it a bone mention here I think.
3D Action/Adventure: Legend of Zelda: Breath of the WildObviously. I'd probably enjoy Horizon: Zero Dawn... but lol PS4 and lol inappropriate agenda pushing (in crappy journalism, at least).
Sports: Mario, whatever.I don't play sports games but the Mario series at least makes them more bearable.
Amiibo: BOTW BaseI like that squishy Metroid, but I like giant bendy legs guardian more.
Developer: NintendoI'd get on you for not including more but lol 2017... ain't nobody surpassing Nintendo. Studio MDHR has a lot of potential for an indie.
3rd Person Shooter: I dunno.I've never played any and don't even know enough about them. Splatoon & Resident Evil (erroneously placed or not) interest me most.
Game of the Year: HNNNNNNNGGGGGGG...Instead of just being a jokey boy I actually have a lot of trouble. Mario Odyssey, Breath of the Wild and Cuphead all surpass yearly lists for me and go into some of my favorite games overall. I wanna put Cuphead on the bottom just because of length, but it's so damn unique and brilliant! BOTW was amazing, but doesn't surpass Elder Scrolls or Fallout style just because of the else RPG focus, but I still sunk 100 hours into the damn thing. Mario Odyssey on the other hand is pretty much the paragon of it's style. I guess I gotta go with...
Game of the Year: Mario Odyssey>Action Adventure/Action RPG game of the Year
> No Yakuza 0 option
I can't participate in the voting, sorry.
Echoing Azure's sentiments, No NieR: Automata option??
I can't participate in the voting, sorry
C'mon fam, this isn't no serious board certified highly regulated thing. Just slip your favorite games in where they belong! Just accept the fact that if they compete in the categories against Mario, Zelda or Cuphead your opinion is wrong.