60. Sonic CD (Switch)
Growing up, I wasn't even aware of Sonic CD's existence until years later when I began collecting video games. Funny enough, most of the online collecting/gaming circles I was a part of talked about Sonic CD like it was the best of the classic Sonic games, and was some unsung masterpiece that was let down by being released on a failed Sega add on console. I first played Sonic CD over 10-years ago with much enthusiasm, only to fond the game to not only be the weakest of the classic Sonic games (not including spinoff titles or handheld games), but fairly underwhelming overall. I decided to revisit Sonic CD to see if maybe my opinion of it either improved or decreased over the years. Unfortunately, it's about the same.
Sonic CD is not a bad game, it's just fairly underwhelming compared to Sonic, Sonic 2, and Sonic 3 + Knuckles. My main issue with Sonic CD is the level design which with a few exceptions and certain sections of the game's stages, do not have a good flow to them and will pretty much just have you bouncing randomly around a stage. Speaking of the stages, I never found any of the stages in Sonic 3 to be that memorable, and even with the time travel gimmick that changes the appearance of the stage you're in and its music, none of them really jumped out at me as memorable unlike the other classic Sonic titles. The presentation overall in Sonic CD is a bit of a mixed bag, but overall I'd say it's a prety good looking Genesis game, but again, it falls short of the other Genesis Sonic games of this time. Finally, there's the game's OST, which is without a doubt the best part of Sonic CD. And despite saying this, I have to say once more, compared to the original 3 Sonic games, the OST just isn't as good, despite being great in its own right. I know a lot of people adore Sonic CD, and while I can acknowledge it's a pretty fun game in a lot of ways, I still find it the weakest of the mainline Genesis Sonic titles. (12/29/23) [31/50]