Wow, I can't believe I didn't think about this game when I saw this topic.
It's another modern one that gets unwarranted hate:
This game is REALLY good. Moreso for fans of the originals, since it's essentially a remake of the first 2 games but it goes WAY deep story-wise. The combat is some of the best this gen, the story is amazing, the characters are great, the voice acting is perfect (especially Jim Cummings as the Terror Mask)... Not only that, but it includes the 3 first games as unlockables (with the arcade version of the first, rather than the slightly lamer TurboGrafx-16 version). Just a great package. It has minor problems (loooong loading times being the biggest one), but nothing that will really bother real gamers... Love this game.