Here is the current state of my retro gameroom. We have our handhelds in another area with books and our relatively current games in the living room.
What are you using for the controllers? Link?
It's a shoe organizer from Target. I got it on clearance, but I think it's usually $18. Not a bad deal. The room has two doors, but we always keep that door closed, so it works really well for that organizer. It also doesn't behave like crummy organizers, the door opens and closes easy with the hooks on the top, I give it a solid 5/5. It even has a little shelf on the top, I put two of my bigger less used controllers up there.
The closet has about 10 of those pink bins (in blue color as well) with all of my accessories relatively well sorted by system... as well as like 10 boxes of duplicates, my 20th anniversary ps4, old old systems (atari, odyssey, TI-94/a, arcadia 2001, etc.), and my oversized controllers (ps2 chainsaw, n64 steering wheel, donkey konga bongos, etc.)
One of my steel battalion sets is in another closet with all of the guitar hero/rock band junk. Finally got the disc for steel battalion yesterday, need to try it out. I have another steel battalion set at my brother's apartment about a 4 hour drive from me, need to drive up there one Sunday and pick it up.
/adhd rantings
http://m.target.com/p/whitmor-over-the-door-shoe-shelves-brown/-/A-16960718
This might be it, doesnt look like it has the little area on the top, but hard to tell.Derp. It's this one.
http://m.target.com/p/threshold-shoe-organizer-with-metal-grommet-26-pockets/-/A-17162526