What I was thinking was a wish list that is basically determined by the price limit. Im sure most people here have a sealed copy of Stadium events on their own personal wish list but if the limit is, say, $30 then thinking that someone is going to send them that copy of SE is silly.
My own wish list on the forums only has items Im super highly interested and most of them would exceed what I see as the price limit. I have other items Id be interested in, however, that arent listed.
The person that is doing the emails and sending out the list will, unfortunately, know who their person is. But whoever it is should be responsible enough to not push their own special "power"!