84. Red Dead Redemption 2 (PS4)
As a gamer, one of my greatest joys is playing a game that transcends being just a good game, and becomes something way more than that. That little extra touch for me comes in the form of the game being personally meaningful for me in some way. Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2) has become one of the most meaningful, thought provoking, and entertaining games I've not only played in recent years, but throughout my entire life of playing video games. My first playthrough of RDR2 was back in 2021 during the backdrop of COVID-19 hysteria and looming vaccine mandates. While I was undoubtedly doing better than most during this period of time, it was a time where I longed for good escapism, which RDR2 delivered in spades, but also gave me something even more in relation to what was happening in the world around me. It made me long to get away from society and the bullshit of the modern world as much as possible. And while I am in no way a hardened outdoorsman or some outlaw trying to escape the spread of modernism, the game partially inspired me to move to a pretty rural part of the country where I work remotely. That was over three years ago and it has gone down as one of the best decisions I've ever made from nearly every possible way of looking at it. No other game, even my favorite games of all time, Shenmue and Shenmue II have inspired me to make a life changing decision like moving out of state and to an area with a fraction of the population where I once lived. That alone, should give you an idea of how much I adore and love this game, but with this being a mini review, I have to go into that even more.
RDR2 is a nearly perfect game. By far the best part of this game is it's incredible writing, story, and characters. This game is one of the best, most well written works of fiction I have ever experienced, video game or otherwise. I cared for many of this characters in this game more than I have some people I've known personally, and the things that happened top them, both good and bad, impacted me in a way few other movies, books, shows, or games ever had. I seriously cannot get enough of this games story and all the incredibly interesting aspects of it. Every exchange of dialogue, whether it was between two main characters during a pivotal part of the story, or just you chatting with a bounty strapped to your horse, I couldn't get enough of the dialogue and writing. It's thanks to the absolutely amazing story and writing that it got me through one of my least favorite parts of the game, the gameplay.
Saying RDR2's gameplay is my least favorite part of the game compared to the story is like saying, I prefer $10,000,000 instead of $9,000,000. Both would be amazing to have, but one is obviously better than the other. The core gameplay of RDR2 is excellent, as is all the side gameplay content like fishing, gambling, going to plays and theatrical productions, and all the other things you can do that greatly enhance your immersion into RDR2's world. While there are a few annoyances here and there, most of this is dwarfed by how good the rest of the game is. Perhaps the only noteworthy blemish on RDR2's gameplay is its somewhat repetitive nature, particularly when completing missions throughout the game. Obviously, you play as an outlaw and do outlaw things often like rob people and businesses, kill rival gang members, and pull off elaborate heists. However, the core gameplay of shooting things often, while well implemented, is just a bit too simple and starts to feel a little arcady almost towards the halfway mark in the game. Don't get me wrong, I do love me some arcade games, but in a game like this, it does stick out like a sore thumb to the point where I just wanted to get past certain shootout sections just to see the next portion of the game play out.
One other issue I have with this game is its epilogue. This I guess this is more of a story gripe rather than a gameplay one, the epilogue is very anticlimactic compared to how the main story ends. I sort of wish Rockstar would have made the epilogue a post credits options source of additional story and content rather than a seamless transition into it after a very decisive and impactful ending to the main game. Nothing you do during the epilogue, including the final confrontation felt rewarding, and almost comes across as mundane fan service to tie into the first RDR's story. With all that said, the epilogue isn't terrible, far from it, but I wish it had been handled and implemented differently.
Unlike the gameplay, I have absolutely no complaints with RDR2's presentation. Both from an visual and audio standpoint, this game is phenomenal and still holds up incredibly well. I can't remember a single voice actor or character in this game, especially among the main characters that doesn't deliver one of the best video game performances I've ever seen. It really helps elevate the story and writing to the level of importance I talked about earlier. While sound effects and the music in RDR2 are certainly part of why the audio in this game are so damn good, it's that amazing voice acting that practically carries the audio of RDR2 on its own.
Visuals are also perfect in my book. Character animations, both in game and during cutscenes are amazing, however what really steals the show in RDR2 is the amazing environment and open world you have around you to explore. Despite how long the main story of this game, I practically doubled my playtime by doing every side quest I possible could just to see more of RDR2's incredible world. I even just went off exploring between missions, like I was on some sort of expedition of adventure. Seeing so many gorgeous vistas, both in the distance and up close is truly breathtaking, and overall this is a game that inspires with its unbelievable beauty. I never wanted to fast travel in this game, and well, I never did, even if I'd been through a certain section of the map a dozen times or more. There is just so much to see and discover in this game, and that is in large part ot how wonderful it all looks.
I adored RDR2 the first time I played it in 2021, however I ended up loving this game even more during m second playthrough. I enjoyed it so much, in fact, that it has been promoted to my third favorite game of all time, moving Ocarina of Time to its previous spot at number four. Being in my top 10 games of all time is no small feat, but being in the top 3 is truly a statement. A game has to really hit me on a personal level to make it that high up, and RDR2 undoubtedly has. RDR2 is an absolute masterpiece of a game and one I cannot stress enough that people go play if they haven't. The game literally changed my life, and even if it doesn't do that for others, it's at the very least one of the best, most well made games ever made. (8/11/25) [48/50]