Listing Errors 2015

[fighterpilot562]

PGA Tour is missing from the list.

http://www.gamestop.com/ps4/games/pga-tour/119146

Missing items wouldn't really count as "listing errors."  It'd count as a good opportunity for someone to add an upcoming title to our database

All items were created by users of the site, so if you see an item is missing, feel free to add it yourself (after searching/browsing first, of course  ).

Aw ok thanks

[psydswipe]

Not sure this belongs here but I didn't want to start a new thread just for this. An edit was rejected and I just wanted to point out why I suggested changing a title. You have Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Survivor 2: Record Breaker and the edit I submitted removed the second set of colons, which is how Atlus has it on the sales sheet. It's possible the sale sheet could have an error though that seemed like the most reliable source.

[pacpix]

Page 1:

• Nintendo 3DS eShop [AU] needs to be added to database to transfer Gunman Clive 2 into correct category.

Page 3:

• Need N64[AS]? category for http://vgcollect.com/item/63551

[pacpix]

Not sure this belongs here but I didn't want to start a new thread just for this. An edit was rejected and I just wanted to point out why I suggested changing a title. You have Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Survivor 2: Record Breaker and the edit I submitted removed the second set of colons, which is how Atlus has it on the sales sheet. It's possible the sale sheet could have an error though that seemed like the most reliable source.

I based my decision off of this section of the Style Guide:

Games with subtitles:  Subtitle should follow the main title after a colon.

Advance Wars: Dual Strike
Bionic Commando: ReArmed
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night
Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire

We do not necessarily go by the title from official site, game review sites, etc.

[psydswipe]

Not sure this belongs here but I didn't want to start a new thread just for this. An edit was rejected and I just wanted to point out why I suggested changing a title. You have Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Survivor 2: Record Breaker and the edit I submitted removed the second set of colons, which is how Atlus has it on the sales sheet. It's possible the sale sheet could have an error though that seemed like the most reliable source.

I based my decision off of this section of the Style Guide:

Games with subtitles:  Subtitle should follow the main title after a colon.

Advance Wars: Dual Strike
Bionic Commando: ReArmed
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night
Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire

We do not necessarily go by the title from official site, game review sites, etc.

I would never base a title from a game review site either and not necessarily an official site as those do tend to contain errors. I'm using the marketing materials that Atlus provides to retailers I'm not trying to argue the point, just thought I should state the source and I understand that colons go before a subtitle but I didn't think it applied in this case since nothing needs to be there.

[kevininja]

Star Wars: Starfighter (PS2)[EU]
http://vgcollect.com/item/59575

Back Boxart uses the whole NA boxart and the Cart/Disc/Media Art uses the NA disc.
Couldn't find the EU back boxart and the EU Cart/Disc/Media Art so I'm posting it here.

[badATchaos]

In January a user created an entry for the white (Japanese) Smash Bros GameCube controller. I recently bought the Japanese release of both the black and white controller and was planning on creating an entry for the black Japanese one. Then I saw the entry title of the existing white entry. "GameCube Controller - Super Smash Bros. Japanese White Edition" That's a mouth full. I was thinking it could be named "GameCube Controller - Super Smash Bros. Edition (White) [JP], but that would be silly also. So I ended up translating word for word what is on the boxes.

Nintendo GameCube
Controller
Smash Bros. White

Nintendo GameCube
Controller
Smash Bros. Black

I feel those names are a lot more elegant than "GameCube Controller - Super Smash Bros. Japanese White Edition." I'll submit edits; feel free to decline them. 
Edit: Or.... should we stand together and remove regions from controllers once and for all?

[mastafafik]

In January a user created an entry for the white (Japanese) Smash Bros GameCube controller. I recently bought the Japanese release of both the black and white controller and was planning on creating an entry for the black Japanese one. Then I saw the entry title of the existing white entry. "GameCube Controller - Super Smash Bros. Japanese White Edition" That's a mouth full. I was thinking it could be named "GameCube Controller - Super Smash Bros. Edition (White) [JP], but that would be silly also. So I ended up translating word for word what is on the boxes.

Nintendo GameCube
Controller
Smash Bros. White

Nintendo GameCube
Controller
Smash Bros. Black

I feel those names are a lot more elegant than "GameCube Controller - Super Smash Bros. Japanese White Edition." I'll submit edits; feel free to decline them. 

I agree with that, they are more elegant and simple, easier to find out in database.

[campercarl]

Deletion request of an AU Listing of an EU/NA/JP only game:
http://vgcollect.com/item/78358
Looked around everywhere for confirmation it had its own AU release. Gamefaqs, mobygames, coverproject, wikipedia and even eBay turn up nothing.
The user who submitted it "f15azza" has submitted a couple other games to, often without correct punctuation and grammar on the title or even correct box art. Might want to politely send him a message about how to properly submit new items.

[tripredacus]

Deletion request of an AU Listing of an EU/NA/JP only game:
http://vgcollect.com/item/78358
Looked around everywhere for confirmation it had its own AU release. Gamefaqs, mobygames, coverproject, wikipedia and even eBay turn up nothing.
The user who submitted it "f15azza" has submitted a couple other games to, often without correct punctuation and grammar on the title or even correct box art. Might want to politely send him a message about how to properly submit new items.

The game does exist, but the user uploaded the wrong picture and needs to fix the title.

Australian release of Automobili Lamborghini is the same as the EU release but it has the Australian rating sticker on it. I found a couple on Ebay.com.au like this one:
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/261792865038
Here's one with better pictures:
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/231475296007

[tripredacus]

Wrong artwork

Power Instinct (Hardware)
http://vgcollect.com/item/72530

[argyle]

This is listed in the wrong category (and that's just the first issue this one has ) - I'm about to create a correct one under Playstation Network (Vita).

http://vgcollect.com/item/59390

[gamingpenguin]

There is two Batman Origins in the Wii U (EU) section. This is the first, and then the second says '(PEGI Rating)' at the end of the title, but the first one also has a PEGI rating? so I am not sure how this is suppose to be, because the second does seem to have a slightly different cover, but there isn't a difference of the rating

http://vgcollect.com/item/68144

This is the second one.

http://vgcollect.com/item/69402



Dirt 2 for the Wii is in the Wii U section, there is already a Dirt 2 in the Wii section so moving it would cause a duplicate.

http://vgcollect.com/item/71461

[tripredacus]

There is two Batman Origins in the Wii U (EU) section. This is the first, and then the second says '(PEGI Rating)' at the end of the title, but the first one also has a PEGI rating? so I am not sure how this is suppose to be, because the second does seem to have a slightly different cover, but there isn't a difference of the rating

http://vgcollect.com/item/68144

This is the second one.

http://vgcollect.com/item/69402

They have different part numbers, as they are two different releases. The titles merely need to be fixed.

From what I can tell, the first one (68144) is the German version. So likely its title should have [DE] in it.

Second one (69402) appears to be the UK release. The "(PEGI Rating)" in the title should be removed, unless it is a variant.

[gamingpenguin]

There is two Batman Origins in the Wii U (EU) section. This is the first, and then the second says '(PEGI Rating)' at the end of the title, but the first one also has a PEGI rating? so I am not sure how this is suppose to be, because the second does seem to have a slightly different cover, but there isn't a difference of the rating

http://vgcollect.com/item/68144

This is the second one.

http://vgcollect.com/item/69402

They have different part numbers, as they are two different releases. The titles merely need to be fixed.

From what I can tell, the first one (68144) is the German version. So likely its title should have [DE] in it.

Second one (69402) appears to be the UK release. The "(PEGI Rating)" in the title should be removed, unless it is a variant.

That would make sense, I spent ages looking at the two and couldn't figure out the difference other than the cover



Also here's a game in the Wii U section, that wasn't released for the Wii U, it seems people are getting that section confused with the Wii one

http://vgcollect.com/item/34471