Error Listings and rejected edits 2023

[nathan776]

Apparently when submitting items for https://vgcollect.com/item/136966 I didn't pay attention to the barcode. Barcode is for DE version and my changes were for a UK version. 

[tripredacus]

Apparently when submitting items for https://vgcollect.com/item/136966 I didn't pay attention to the barcode. Barcode is for DE version and my changes were for a UK version.

Barcode removed

[endemonadia]

Ive just had a disc image rejected due to being classed as the wrong one.  Its correct.

Weirdly the entire release of the FIRST edition was issued with a French game disc.  You can see this if you peruse Ebay and see that all of the game discs the game title is written in French.  The second release (Ubisoft Exclusive) had the correct English disc. 

This item came with a French disc.
https://vgcollect.com/item/70913

This one has the English disc.
https://vgcollect.com/item/175838

NOTE: here is an example of the first release with the French disc on Ebay
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/195762729049?hash=item2d945e3059%3Ag%3Ak5IAAOSwJ9li3TNp&amdata=enc%3AAQAIAAAA4NVR7DYj2TLCaNvNH%2Br%2BOc%2FbZCKqiKLxZAuSYjUF4ulBncedKViefnXZCEwb4lHDXaxCZZRBywVq5IdcO2BhWEs%2F9F%2FvlwYbj0OEdJLcqmzxRW2IGlBHUmsYks7A%2FeRCnpt5i%2FFgYlnVDYh2sFBUrxio%2FvC1fDazJYZ%2BL6dM6c%2BwRSBOsGfxHR8QBdyxqluEax2lNBrIV5HuYhKCu1xu1c0Z%2BOCc2HfGN4bl8hkR6jlkD693StbI4ift0mSEM9YMH28OeTNRIeu%2Blf0Ft8Oh5reHmdk%2BL8jf4OFDCYTjbknR%7Ctkp%3ABk9SR7666ZPBYg&LH_BIN=1

[tripredacus]

I will do an audit to determine this.
I want to point out that this entry has been frankensteined, so it must be corrected first anyways.
There is nothing original to this entry left, so it must be UK version only.
I'll let you know what I find out.

[tripredacus]

OK I have completed it for now, regarding existing entries and some notes on missing entries.

Dukes of Hazzard Racing From Home: https://vgcollect.com/item/70913
other spine item number: 2805056
front item number: 3307212805056
has the Ubisoft logo and USK/ELSPA 11 on back
- found with SLES-02343/0001 FR disc in UK
- found with SLES-02343 FR disc outside of UK

Dukes of Hazzard Racing From Home Ubisoft Exclusive: https://vgcollect.com/item/175838
found with SLES-02343# EN disc

Sherif Fais-Moi Peur: https://vgcollect.com/item/129777
found with SLES-02343 FR disc
example: https://www.ebay.fr/itm/184610192635

Sherif Fais-Moi Peur Ubisoft Exclusive: https://vgcollect.com/item/66443
found with SLES-02343 FR disc

There does not appear to be any SLES-02343 EN discs
The German releases have the 02343 FR disc in regular version and the 02343# EN disc in Ubisoft Exclusive

Not in DB
Italian versions are just the German versions with SAIE labels.
Found one PT version that is labelled of one of the UK versions but can't see disc number: https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/125710332358

There are various combinations that I did not list above for UK or general EU release that I cannot say for sure are not piecemealed. There are many instances of the UE disc being in the non UE cases. Because they appear to be peicemealed, we have to be on the side of caution and not put them into the DB unless we can find difinitive proof it exists... aka someone has to open a sealed copy and find that disc in there.

So for the entry in question (70913)
This one can be changed to (SLES-02343/0001 disc)
and have the info I posted above be put into description. Then the disc scan with that item number can be put.
Also in description goes item number for disc and the title title. In alt-name you put in the French name.

Then make a new entry for the variant with descriptor (SLES-02343 disc)
And that entry can have that French disc picture. Everything else on the entry would be the same as the other, but disc item number in desc would be different.

Update the others and add the missing ones at your leisure.

[nathan776]

Does this item exist? https://vgcollect.com/item/221941
I've looked up ebay, vinted and allegro - which either seem to offer the ESRB version or a key to the game.
https://vgcollect.com/item/160004 also does not exist in EU



Going to replace the back of https://vgcollect.com/item/138218 . Front is UK , back is NL

[dhaabi]

Going to replace the back of https://vgcollect.com/item/138218 . Front is UK , back is NL

When overwriting data in any way relating to mixed entry corrections, it is best to submit a new entry for the data's corresponding item. I've created a new entry for Assassin's Creed: The Ezio Collection [NL].

[fazerco]

Apparently when submitting items for https://vgcollect.com/item/136966 I didn't pay attention to the barcode. Barcode is for DE version and my changes were for a UK version.

Barcode removed

Pegi 7 front, pegi 3 back, frankenstein item.

[nathan776]

https://vgcollect.com/item/185523 also doesnt exist

[dhaabi]

Apparently when submitting items for https://vgcollect.com/item/136966 I didn't pay attention to the barcode. Barcode is for DE version and my changes were for a UK version.

Barcode removed

Pegi 7 front, pegi 3 back, frankenstein item.

The front art for 136966 has since been updated, but this is not something to report. Before, the entry featured outdated stock art. While this kind of art is incorrect and obviously could be updated to better reflect the actual item, our guidelines state that such kind of art is admissible. Instead of reporting instances of wrong stock art, simply submit the appropriate changes for them to be approved.

Also, this was not an instance of a mixed or "frankenstein" entry.

[tripredacus]

Frankenstein entries rarely are things these days, rather most that appear that way are entries that were partially converted in the past.

[endemonadia]

The listing https://vgcollect.com/item/221733 is the re-release under [Midas] and i am going to make the amendment now. 

I have just put together the listing for the original and i will put this up also now.  The reason i am posting this here is because the one thats listed in the database has the title needed for the original.

There is another listing on the database for this game https://vgcollect.com/item/90191 and that is correct.

This title - Heroes of Might and Magic: Quest for the DragonBone Staff

[dhaabi]

The listing https://vgcollect.com/item/221733 is the re-release under [Midas] and i am going to make the amendment now. 

I have just put together the listing for the original and i will put this up also now.  The reason i am posting this here is because the one thats listed in the database has the title needed for the original.

There is another listing on the database for this game https://vgcollect.com/item/90191 and that is correct.

This title - Heroes of Might and Magic: Quest for the DragonBone Staff

Edit submission rejected, and I have left the entry as it for you to correct it upon reviewing why that is the case. Brackets are reserved for TLDs only, so something like [Midas] is incorrect and will always be rejected. I mentioned it in the Admin comments, but I will repeat here that the correct name for 221733 should be Heroes of Might and Magic: Quest for the DragonBone Staff (Midas).

90191 was not correct. I have updated its name to omit the attached [UK] TLD.

[psxlegacy]

As far as I have read online, this game has been cancelled and never released (cancelation coming recently, but 3 years after release date).

Bounty Battle (PS4)

https://vgcollect.com/item/179419

Not sure if the cancellation also applies to the other console versions, but gamefaqs has the ps4 entry as cancelled.

[endemonadia]

I just had an edit rejected and im very confused with the changes you have made to the original listing.

I submitted a rear case scan of the True Crime Streets of LA to this listing https://vgcollect.com/item/31604 - this listing had the incorrect rear scan a Dutch edition scan.

You rejected that scan saying that this listing was for [NL].  The listing was originally not listed as [NL] you have added that into the title when you rejected my rear scan.  You have also changed the barcode.  I ALWAYS look at the barcode as the principle indicator of the database entry and this entry was 100% not the [NL] release except for the incorrect rear case scan that was on the listing.  The barcode was originally the correct common release (ending 128).

This [NL] listing now has 128 people saying this is in their collection.  I dont think that most people have the [NL] copy of this game which is much rarer release.

You have also created a new entry for the common release of this game which uses my rear scan https://vgcollect.com/item/252886 - this common release is not in anyones collection.

I dont understand why you changed the barcode on the original listing and created a new entry for the common release.