Error Listings and rejected edits 2024

[dhaabi]

https://vgcollect.com/item/181595

Got two rejected edits related to text.

As mentioned, the text that's listed on the box_text value is on the front cover, not on the back.

Game bought today, brand-new.

As mentioned in the rejection comments, your submission was rejected due to trying to remove valid Box Text field information and transferring it to the Description field where it's not needed. If you re-submit the information again while maintaining what's already present, it will be approved.

The Box Text field isn't exclusive to back cover text, though it's generally unwarranted to add in many cases. The existing text mentioning compatibility is relevant and useful as well as being information that's exclusive to that item variant (see 275326.)

[theodw]

As mentioned in the rejection comments, your submission was rejected due to trying to remove valid Box Text field information and transferring it to the Description field where it's not needed. If you re-submit the information again while maintaining what's already present, it will be approved.

Done, including the all caps for the text already present.

Also, isn't the item number (78550206US in this case) supposed to only be filled in case that it's present on the spine? This game doesn't have that number on the spine, but on the top right of the barcode area.

[dhaabi]

As mentioned in the rejection comments, your submission was rejected due to trying to remove valid Box Text field information and transferring it to the Description field where it's not needed. If you re-submit the information again while maintaining what's already present, it will be approved.

Done, including the all caps for the text already present.

Also, isn't the item number (78550206US in this case) supposed to only be filled in case that it's present on the spine? This game doesn't have that number on the spine, but on the top right of the barcode area.

Approved.

As for the Item Number field, the spine number is prioritized. However, item number locations are not uniform, so there is an order of hierarchy that's outlined in the style guide. So, for instance, if neither a spine number nor back number is present but a front number is, then that front number information should be submitted to the dedicated field.

Items with multiple numbers
The priority list of which number is added to the item number field in the DB is:
1. The spine or side
2. The back
3. The front
4. The media
5. Hidden or only on sealed samples
Additional item numbers should be put into the description.

[theodw]

As for the Item Number field, the spine number is prioritized. However, item number locations are not uniform, so there is an order of hierarchy that's outlined in the style guide. So, if neither a spine number nor back number is present but a front number is, then that front number information should be submitted to the dedicated field.

Oh, okay. In that case, I'll fix the entries for the other XB1 games I have around here.

[NickAwesome]

Can we compromise and edit it to be Ishidō?

When I rejected your submissions, I was under the impression that we prioritized transliteration over transcription, but this seems to be only relevant regarding JP items. So, NA and EU entry pages have been reverted back to Ishidō, whereas JP entry pages maintain Ishidou.

Several of the entries were previously titled Ishidō: The Way of the Stones which is incorrect, so there should be greater uniformity now.

Thanks for updating!  The uniformity is appreciated.