Error Listings and rejected edits 2023

[price5474]

Ended up with a blank entry.

https://vgcollect.com/item/238676

[price5474]

https://vgcollect.com/item/238897

blank one.

[Agozer]

https://vgcollect.com/item/186332

I'm fairly sure this one should have the [UK] tag at the end of the title.

[vivigamer]

Unless I am wrong, I thought there was not a Phsyical Release of Nier: Automata - Become as Gods Edition on Xbox One?
Physical - https://vgcollect.com/item/145763
Digital - https://vgcollect.com/item/181990

[tripredacus]

Unless I am wrong, I thought there was not a Phsyical Release of Nier: Automata - Become as Gods Edition on Xbox One?
Physical - https://vgcollect.com/item/145763
Digital - https://vgcollect.com/item/181990

It doesn't look there is a physical release in a box like on that front art, but is there a code card? There are code card mockups on Ebay, if a code card exists than it can be put into that category.

[snyderec3]

Can I get some clarification as to why the update to the release date of FF Pixel Remaster was rejected?



Unless I am misunderstanding, the comment seems to be saying that this is a digital only release?

This is incorrect, as I have the physical release in my possession:

[dhaabi]

Can I get some clarification as to why the update to the release date of FF Pixel Remaster was rejected?

Unless I am misunderstanding, the comment seems to be saying that this is a digital only release?

This is incorrect, as I have the physical release in my possession

Because these items are new, there is limited information about them using typical sources our site relies upon, such as GameFAQs (release date Q2 2023) and eBay (all available and sold listings utilize marketing art), which is still the case. I could not verify any item being a "FF35th Anniversary Edition" having been released. Currently, the two entries FF35th Anniversary Edition entries feature no art—however, they before featured the same artwork as the standard releases and not anything specific as to what the FF3th Anniversary Edition actually looks like. I removed that artwork to avoid further confusion.

Now, I can not verify anything from your photo pertinent to the item itself. Is the large item a box? Does it mention FF35th Anniversary Edition anywhere on the box itself? If not, then the entry should be renamed to Final Fantasy Pixel Remaster (box) with FF35th Anniversary Edition supplied to the Alt-name field. Was the actual game keepcase housed inside of the box, or was it packaged separately? If the latter, then the entry will need to be moved to a Swag category. I am asking now because this is a ongoing trend with limited edition type items.

For now, obviously the entry's information can be updated to Official Release with April 2023 as the Release Date. To my knowledge, this item is exclusive to online storefronts only, so determining when the item was actually available in-hand after mailing is difficult. For instance, the item may have had an advertised April 19 2023 date, but the information you submitted was on April 18 2023, so it seems that there are some who received the item early, and there are surely some who have yet to receive their pre-order. The "[d]igital only" comment could have been better explained, but I could only verify the digital item having releasing on April 19.

[snyderec3]

Can I get some clarification as to why the update to the release date of FF Pixel Remaster was rejected?

Unless I am misunderstanding, the comment seems to be saying that this is a digital only release?

This is incorrect, as I have the physical release in my possession

Because these items are new, there is limited information about them using typical sources our site relies upon, such as GameFAQs (release date Q2 2023) and eBay (all available and sold listings utilize marketing art), which is still the case. I could not verify any item being a "FF35th Anniversary Edition" having been released. Currently, the two entries FF35th Anniversary Edition entries feature no art—however, they before featured the same artwork as the standard releases and not anything specific as to what the FF3th Anniversary Edition actually looks like. I removed that artwork to avoid further confusion.

Now, I can not verify anything from your photo pertinent to the item itself. Is the large item a box? Does it mention FF35th Anniversary Edition anywhere on the box itself? If not, then the entry should be renamed to Final Fantasy Pixel Remaster (box) with FF35th Anniversary Edition supplied to the Alt-name field. Was the actual game keepcase housed inside of the box, or was it packaged separately? If the latter, then the entry will need to be moved to a Swag category. I am asking now because this is a ongoing trend with limited edition type items.

For now, obviously the entry's information can be updated to Official Release with April 2023 as the Release Date. To my knowledge, this item is exclusive to online storefronts only, so determining when the item was actually available in-hand after mailing is difficult. For instance, the item may have had an advertised April 19 2023 date, but the information you submitted was on April 18 2023, so it seems that there are some who received the item early, and there are surely some who have yet to receive their pre-order. The "[d]igital only" comment could have been better explained, but I could only verify the digital item having releasing on April 19.

The "FF35th Anniversary Edition" does not appear on the game, but rather came from the developer's storefront as seen here. The release date of 19 April 23 is also indicated here:



Some notes on the packaging:
The box contains the limited edition swag that comes with this release.

The game with its lenticular sleeve are packaged together, but separately from the swag box. The standard edition does not have the lenticular sleeve, as per the description of each edition on the storefront.

[tripredacus]

Since Snyderec picture is "compromised" you can see the purchase includes 2 items
- the box
- the game with the sleeve
Seen in this unboxing video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nzv1mEGCoqM

[dhaabi]

Can I get some clarification as to why the update to the release date of FF Pixel Remaster was rejected?

Unless I am misunderstanding, the comment seems to be saying that this is a digital only release?

This is incorrect, as I have the physical release in my possession

Because these items are new, there is limited information about them using typical sources our site relies upon, such as GameFAQs (release date Q2 2023) and eBay (all available and sold listings utilize marketing art), which is still the case. I could not verify any item being a "FF35th Anniversary Edition" having been released. Currently, the two entries FF35th Anniversary Edition entries feature no art—however, they before featured the same artwork as the standard releases and not anything specific as to what the FF3th Anniversary Edition actually looks like. I removed that artwork to avoid further confusion.

Now, I can not verify anything from your photo pertinent to the item itself. Is the large item a box? Does it mention FF35th Anniversary Edition anywhere on the box itself? If not, then the entry should be renamed to Final Fantasy Pixel Remaster (box) with FF35th Anniversary Edition supplied to the Alt-name field. Was the actual game keepcase housed inside of the box, or was it packaged separately? If the latter, then the entry will need to be moved to a Swag category. I am asking now because this is a ongoing trend with limited edition type items.

For now, obviously the entry's information can be updated to Official Release with April 2023 as the Release Date. To my knowledge, this item is exclusive to online storefronts only, so determining when the item was actually available in-hand after mailing is difficult. For instance, the item may have had an advertised April 19 2023 date, but the information you submitted was on April 18 2023, so it seems that there are some who received the item early, and there are surely some who have yet to receive their pre-order. The "[d]igital only" comment could have been better explained, but I could only verify the digital item having releasing on April 19.

The "FF35th Anniversary Edition" does not appear on the game, but rather came from the developer's storefront as seen here. The release date of 19 April 23 is also indicated here:

Some notes on the packaging:
The box contains the limited edition swag that comes with this release.

The game with its lenticular sleeve are packaged together, but separately from the swag box. The standard edition does not have the lenticular sleeve, as per the description of each edition on the storefront.

So, because of how this "one" release was packaged with the game being separate from the actual limited edition item, the two FF35th Anniversary Edition entries have been condensed into one and then placed in the Swag - Toys/Novelties category. The lenticular sleeve is also able to have its own unique entry placed in the Nintendo Switch Accessories category based on the same criteria.

I've updated the one 35th Anniversary Edition entry. If you are wanting to add the actual Final Fantasy Pixel Remaster game to your collection, then a Switch entry for it already exists.

[62gaming]

Here to preempt a possible rejection. I edited the following item: https://vgcollect.com/item/31910 to add on "(CD)" as this entry uses a version that has an extra sticker/label to indicate it has a CD included as a first time limited benefit (I'm guessing that means a first print run bonus sort of deal). There exists copies without the sticker/label but as I don't own one myself I don't feel comfortable adding it, plus it seems like the CD version is a lot more common anyhow.

If you think "(CD)" is lacking in description, please feel free to adjust it as you like.

[tripredacus]

Here to preempt a possible rejection. I edited the following item: https://vgcollect.com/item/31910 to add on "(CD)" as this entry uses a version that has an extra sticker/label to indicate it has a CD included as a first time limited benefit (I'm guessing that means a first print run bonus sort of deal). There exists copies without the sticker/label but as I don't own one myself I don't feel comfortable adding it, plus it seems like the CD version is a lot more common anyhow.

If you think "(CD)" is lacking in description, please feel free to adjust it as you like.

Pre-emptive posts before edits rarely will help because going to the forum isn't first thing we do. Sorry.

Anyways there is one without the label on Mercari and doesn't include the CD, and one without the label on YAJ that does include the CD. So at this point, if it can't be confirmed with a sealed copy that a release without the label exists, then we will have to believe that any instances without the label are just ones where the label was removed. If we/someone finds a sealed one later (or is able to otherwise confirm the release) we can add the var then.

[vivigamer]

Hi just a question,

I've seen on the PS5 Listings their are PSVR2 Boxsets listed under the games catagory, would this not be better suited to accessories?
https://vgcollect.com/item/238698

I know it includes a Digital version of Horizon Call of the Mountain but as it is not a physical copy of  the game I would have thought that wouldn't count. Nit-picky I know but I saw it and thought I may as well check - Sorry if this topic has been brought up alreadys.

I looked to see an unboxing to confirm the Horizon game is on a code:
https://youtu.be/E33cKjlML9I?t=232

[dhaabi]

I've seen on the PS5 Listings their are PSVR2 Boxsets listed under the games catagory, would this not be better suited to accessories?
https://vgcollect.com/item/238698

I know it includes a Digital version of Horizon Call of the Mountain but as it is not a physical copy of  the game I would have thought that wouldn't count. Nit-picky I know but I saw it and thought I may as well check - Sorry if this topic has been brought up alreadys.

I looked to see an unboxing to confirm the Horizon game is on a code:
https://youtu.be/E33cKjlML9I?t=232

The Horizon Call of the Mountain example is no different than the code-in-a-box items placed in physical categories which include vouchers. The idea is that the voucher is still a physical component, unlike some instances where items only include the game code separately via e-mail or paper receipt.

That being said, it seems as if you understand that accessories with games and games with accessories are to be placed in Game categories and not Accessories categories, so for these items to be placed in PlayStation 5 categories is correct.

[smesgr]

https://vgcollect.com/item/139908
picture is not of the "limited day one edition". Those should have a banner below the PS4 logo. Like the Xbox release https://vgcollect.com/item/234076