Error Listings and rejected edits 2023

[dhaabi]

Grid Legend on PS4. Listing under [NA] region shows [MX] version and wrong cover image.

[NA] categories allow for more than just US releases. CA and MX releases are allowed as well. Submit a new entry for whichever release you are wanting to add, because the existing MX entry is not to be changed.

[mrmette]

Rejected edit to Analogue Pocket Dock.
https://vgcollect.com/item/168549

The release date was rejected because:
Admin comments: Items shipped and received sometime in 2023. "Fulfillment Group C: 2023" https://store.analogue.co

But this is Group C, so the 3rd fulfillment group. The first one was sent out at the end of 2021, I don't know when the second one was sent out.

All the products had an actual release date of December 2021, but there were a lot of delays because they had trouble getting the correct chips because of COVID.
I managed to get the actual Analogue Pocket in group A, it was sent out to me on December 14th 2021. I didn't order the dock back then, but the dock released at the same time.

I ordered my dock a little after that and got a Group C fullfilment date (so 2023) with that order. I just received my dock a week or 2 ago.

I am sure the original release date was December 13th 2021, just like the Analogue Pocket itself was.
https://vgcollect.com/item/168444

[dhaabi]

Rejected edit to Analogue Pocket Dock.
https://vgcollect.com/item/168549

Thanks for the clarification. Because this is an online exclusive item, I've refrained from updating the Day field since we cannot determine exactly when the item was actually received by those ordering it. December 2021 is fine, which I confirmed from YouTube unboxing videos.

I do not recall seeing an edit for the Release Type which has recently been approved for Official Release, but I have again updated it to Unofficial Release.

[nathan776]

https://vgcollect.com/item/87942

Barcode to image is 887256023577

887256015787 is a different version (Contains pre-order bonus)




https://vgcollect.com/item/154620
Image has SIAE but barcode is UK Release. Not sure if this would be an issue.

[tripredacus]

https://vgcollect.com/item/154620
Image has SIAE but barcode is UK Release. Not sure if this would be an issue.

Not SIAE, it is the Playstation hologram.

[dhaabi]

https://vgcollect.com/item/154620
Image has SIAE but barcode is UK Release. Not sure if this would be an issue.

Not SIAE, it is the Playstation hologram.

The SIAE label is present.

[tripredacus]

I didn't even see it.
Anyways, Italy sometimes will import multiple versions, so you'll have to do a deep look on this if possible.

[brownd]

Hi, need to clarify an edit I was making on this item:
https://vgcollect.com/item/205435

I was adding the (Premium) descriptor to distinguish it from the initial release, which I have now submitted as well:
https://vgcollect.com/item/235925

205435 is described as "ES-TRACKMANIA UNITED FOREVER PREMIUM" on back cover, 235925 as "ES-TRACKMANIA UNITED FOREVER".

[dhaabi]

Hi, need to clarify an edit I was making on this item:
https://vgcollect.com/item/205435

I was adding the (Premium) descriptor to distinguish it from the initial release, which I have now submitted as well:
https://vgcollect.com/item/235925

205435 is described as "ES-TRACKMANIA UNITED FOREVER PREMIUM" on back cover, 235925 as "ES-TRACKMANIA UNITED FOREVER".

The original edit you submitted was prior to submitting an entry for the non-Premium version, which is why it was rejected then, as a descriptor would not have been necessary. However, the formatting was also wrong, since there is no need for an attached TLD, as there is currently only one Premium item in the database currently. I've updated the entry name for 205435 to TrackMania United Forever (Premium) as well as updating the Description field to indicate that it's a Spanish release.

With that said, there is also a generic third entry in the category. I can't find any evidence of a non-Spanish release, so this entry may just need to be merged into 235925. If this were done, the ES TLD modifier would then be removed.

[brownd]

The original edit you submitted was prior to submitting an entry for the non-Premium version, which is why it was rejected then, as neither edition formatting or a descriptor would have been necessary.

I realized too late I hadn't clicked the submit button on that one yet, my apologies for the confusion.

With that said, there is also a generic third entry in the category. I can't find any evidence of a non-Spanish release, so this entry may just need to be merged into 235925. If this were done, the ES TLD modifier would then be removed.

Could've been meant for the original French release (digital placeholder artwork matches) which is actually branded as Édition Limitée (Limited Edition) on the box
Only other release I can find without extra branding is this one from Germany.

[dhaabi]

With that said, there is also a generic third entry in the category. I can't find any evidence of a non-Spanish release, so this entry may just need to be merged into 235925. If this were done, the ES TLD modifier would then be removed.

Could've been meant for the original French release (digital placeholder artwork matches) which is actually branded as Édition Limitée (Limited Edition) on the box
Only other release I can find without extra branding is this one from Germany.

What I meant is that there doesn't seem to be a non-Spanish release with the same artwork that isn't some kind of edition release. Since 118377 is generic, we can only work off of its current artwork as that is the only identifying information available to us.

[62gaming]

Accidentally created a blank entry: https://vgcollect.com/item/237343

So it turns out you shouldn't move image files before submitting a new item in the database, I thought images uploaded immediately but they don't.

[nathan776]

Back box art for https://vgcollect.com/item/97614 is incorrect - should feature Pidgey and Rattata in the image as only the 1st release had Sandshrew/Meowth
https://www.ebay.com/itm/385385316638

Additionally I'm not sure the item descriptor works as the second release also changed the back image to Pidgey/Rattata but has a White ESRB rating. Not sure what would be best to change it to. Possibly (White ESRB / Sandshrew) (White ESRB / Pidgey) ?
https://www.ebay.com/itm/325576503802

[dhaabi]

Back box art for https://vgcollect.com/item/97614 is incorrect - should feature Pidgey and Rattata in the image as only the 1st release had Sandshrew/Meowth
https://www.ebay.com/itm/385385316638

Additionally I'm not sure the item descriptor works as the second release also changed the back image to Pidgey/Rattata but has a White ESRB rating. Not sure what would be best to change it to. Possibly (White ESRB / Sandshrew) (White ESRB / Pidgey) ?
https://www.ebay.com/itm/325576503802

I couldn't identify any other discerning information between the two white ESRB boxes, so using the screenshot information as part of the descriptor seems ideal. If the third entry is submitted, then all three entries should be formatted like this:
Pokémon Blue Version (white ESRB / Sandshrew)
Pokémon Blue Version (white ESRB / Rattata)
Pokémon Blue Version (black ESRB)

Then, for all three entries, either "'Enemy RATTATA used TACKLE!' / 'SANDSHREW used POISON STING!' screenshot on back cover" should be submitted to the Description field.

[snyderec3]

This entry for Super Mario World exists despite all variants already having separate entries.

https://vgcollect.com/item/238550

This one has inconsistent information from several variants. The box art is from either the original slotted or locking cartridge variant, which does not mesh with the ESRB rating, as SMW did not receive an ESRB rating until the Player's Choice release. The item number is incorrect. That item number is for the physical shell of the SNES cartridge, not SMW specifically and is present on every SNES game. The barcode is from the EU PAL release, not any of the North American releases.